Council for Innovation Promotion Calls for Accountability for Unsupported HTIA Claim About U.S. Patent Quality

WASHINGTON (November 19, 2026) — Today, Council for Innovation Promotion (C4IP) President and CEO Coke Morgan Stewart issued the following statement in response to the High Tech Inventors Alliance’s (HTIA) claim that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) granted more than 150,000 invalid patents in 2024 — a figure equivalent to more than 46% of all utility patents the agency granted that year.

“HTIA has repeatedly made this extraordinary claim without offering any credible evidence to substantiate it. Presenting such a broad accusation as established fact is irresponsible and misleads policymakers and the public.

“Only a small fraction of patents are ever challenged in federal court or before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. The parties choose which patents to challenge and which claims to contest. The validity outcomes of those disputes therefore cannot establish how often the USPTO granted claims in error across an entire year’s patents.

“A serious assessment of patent quality must examine errors in both directions. Granting a claim that should have been rejected can harm competitors. Rejecting a claim that should have been granted can deny an inventor protection for a legitimate invention. HTIA’s sweeping, unsupported claim does a disservice to the thousands of USPTO examiners who work to uphold the integrity of our patent system and undermines the serious, fact-based debate that patent policy demands.”

About the Council for Innovation Promotion: The Council for Innovation Promotion is a bipartisan coalition dedicated to promoting strong and effective intellectual property rights that drive innovation, boost economic competitiveness, and improve lives everywhere.

Scroll to Top